I was browsing the New York Times Web site today, and found an article called “Swiss Ban Building of Minarets on Mosques” buried in the World Section. THis article about a new referendum that passed Sunday in Switzerland appalled me somewhat.
According to the article, Switzerland has a reputation for religious tolerance, yet the referendum, which bans the building on minarets on mosques in the county, passed by an overwhelming 57.5 percent majority, despite being opposed by the government.
Since I’ve not overly familiar with the Islamic faith, I did some research on what exactly a minaret is and why it is significant to the Islamic faith. According to an Encyclopedia Britannica online article about minarets, it is a tower from which the faithful are called to prayer by the muezzin, or crier. They are attached to the mosque, and have either a balcony or open gallery.
Several online sources say that they are rarely used for this purpose anymore, and are just symbolic. The call to prayer can be made from elsewhere in the mosque, and is sometimes done from a loudspeaker.
The referendum passed by the Swiss this weekend had little to do with the religious aspect of the minarets and more to do with political motives. The referendum was proposed by the rightist Swiss People’s Party.
According to the article, the referendum is thought to have passed because of popular fear of fundamentalist Islamic activities. However, it sends a message against the community as a whole.
What do you think about the referendum? According to the NYT article, there are currently only 4 mosques that have minarets, and only 2 more are planned to be built. The Swiss People’s Party says the minarets are a political symbol, which goes against the constitution of the country, according to a CNN article. Both the NYT and CNN articles say that the party has been responsible for a lot of anti-Islamic propaganda.
There has been considerable backlash against the referendum. According to a Yahoo! news article, Amnesty International has the vote violated freedom of religion. They think it will likely be overturned by the Swiss supreme court or the European Court of Human Rights.
What do you think will happen to the referendum? Will it stand? Or will it get overturned? How do you feel about the obvious anti-Islamic action in a country known for religious tolerance? Will it be well received around the world? Do you think others will copy it?


